Sunlight shines on the bronze cheeks of Cpl. Thomas Carney, the November breeze rustling the oak leaves around him.
He stands atop the small Annapolis hill next to the State House, a place of history since before the American Revolution. The Maryland solider carries the wounded figure of Capt. Perry Benson to a barefoot nurse waiting a few steps away.
Gov. Wes Moore dedicated “Black Patriots: The Pursuit of Transcendent Liberty” on Nov. 1. It replaces one removed years ago of Roger Brooke Taney, the U.S. Supreme Court chief justice who declared before the Civil War that enslaved Black people could never be free citizens.
In Maryland’s small-town state capital, it‘s a symbol not only of American history, but also of what memorials are.
As beautiful as Branly Cadet’s artwork is — how rich the irony of replacing a man who deeply misunderstood liberty with the figure of a man who fought for it — memorials are about power.
Sit on the carved granite bench Cadet placed between the soldiers and the unnamed nurse, and the power it took to make this change should be as clear as Carney and Benson’s clasped hands.
Read More
Thirty-six miles from State Circle, there’s another example of power in memorials. President Donald Trump wants to build a 250-foot-tall triumphal arch next to Arlington National Cemetery across the Potomac River from D.C.
The reasons keep shifting.
At first, he joked it was about him. Then he said it was about the 250th anniversary of the Declaration of Independence. He’s called it the ceremonial entrance to the capital, and a perch for snipers and drones to protect the city.
On Veterans Day, the president said it was a way to honor veterans.
“Soon we’re going to dedicate a magnificent triumphal arc to our veterans, and that’s in honor of our great veterans and our great military,” Trump said during a ceremony at Arlington.

Everyone understands this arch is about him, and his power to achieve it.
Construction is on hold as a judge weighs challenges by veterans, Arlington County and Virginia, the District of Columbia and the Kennedy family.
As proposed, the arch would cast a shadow on the cemetery and, some days, the eternal flame at President John F. Kennedy’s grave that is one of its emotional centerpieces.
Trump is exercising power to remake Washington, from tearing down the East Wing of the White House and building a massive ballroom/bunker complex, to shuttering the Kennedy Center to cutting down trees at a public golf course he wants to redevelop to making his gilded White House bric-a-brac a national monument.
And the arch.

It would dwarf the Arc de Triomphe in Paris, tower over the Washington Square Arch in New York and even edge out the Monumento a la Revolución in Mexico City.
No matter whose memory the arch would officially honor, the public would remember it as the Arc de Trump — and not how the president wants.
Taney is forgotten by many today, but he was a respected Maryland lawyer who presided over the nation’s highest court for 30 years.
When he died in 1864, the Maryland General Assembly commissioned William Henry Rinehart to create a bronze for the State House.
It was the year that Maryland outlawed slavery by a 375-vote margin — Union troops decided it with the state’s first absentee ballots.
On the day Taney’s forlorn figure was unveiled in 1872, white supremacists were back in power, quashing the rights of Maryland’s Black citizens.

Gov. Larry Hogan removed the statue in 2017, part of a wave of reckonings for misplaced Confederate iconography. State House leaders suggested the change and spent years designing a thoughtful replacement.
The Carney statue is not far from the statue of George Washington inside the State House, where he surrendered his military commission at the end of the Revolution. Frederick Douglass and Harriet Tubman are on the second floor, Marylanders who fought for freedom in a struggle different than Washington’s.
In Annapolis, there are statues to firefighters killed in the line of duty, a beloved state tax collector, a German who came to fight for independence and an Italian who decorated the Capitol ceiling in Washington.
There’s a statue of the first Black Supreme Court justice, one of a writer descended from enslaved Africans who made his family’s saga famous with his book “Roots” and a native chief who signed a peace treaty with European colonists.
There’s a memorial to my friends, five journalists killed defending freedom of the press.

Two weeks before Moore dedicated Cadet’s statue, activists dedicated a memorial to Malcom X at the public library, honoring a civil rights figure who credited books for changing his life.
Five days later, Naval Academy alumni dedicated the “Global War on Terror Monument.” It includes 46 names of graduates who died in the 20-plus years of war that followed the 9/11 attacks.
All are symbols of the power to decide what is worth memorializing, who deserves a place in our American pantheon.
Sitting with the figures of Carney, Benson and the shoeless nurse the other day, I tried to imagine what they would say about this moment.
It’s a rhetorical trick that goes back to the ancient Greeks, whose poets put words in the mouths of statues. Newspaper columnists of print’s glory days used it to comedic effect.

The new bronze figures might ask why it took so long for a state and a city that ignored 150 patriots because of their color to correct the injustice.
I wish President Trump would sit on Cadet’s stone bench, listen to the breeze through red-and-gold leaves.
It’s a place to contemplate mistakes by powerful men, and the power it takes to undo them.
Unless the courts stop the president, he will build his arch. He will do it because he has the power.
Memorials are lessons about the present, ones only the future can judge. That is what the three bronze figures on a hill overlooking Annapolis say.
If you listen.






Comments
Welcome to The Banner's subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.