Teresa Fidelis Harris Gagne Lancaster was going to be somebody.
At 14, the girl named for one of her family’s favorite saints was accepted to the prestigious Archbishop Keough High School in southwestern Baltimore County. For the first two years, she was the picture of success: High white socks and clean saddle shoes. Top grades. Evenings, she watched “Perry Mason” with her father, a lawyer, and played “judge,” adjudicating pretend cases while sitting on the family piano bench in a bathrobe. Over summers, she mastered the butterfly stroke.
She was going to be a lawyer. And someday, much later, a mother and wife.
Everything changed on a crisp autumn morning in 1970, when she went to see the school’s counselor, the Rev. Joseph Maskell. Lancaster said what happened that day would repeat itself countless times in her teenage years and has replayed in her memory daily since. Over two years, Maskell repeatedly raped her, Lancaster said, forced her to endure painful douches and enemas, invited his associates to rape her, and occasionally made her best friend watch as he took turns violating the girls.
The horrors of her last two years at Keough stunted her, Lancaster said. Her grades dropped; her dreams faded. Marriage and children — an escape — came earlier than she’d planned. So did the death of her first husband and single motherhood to four children.
She rarely spoke of it. But in 1992, fellow student Jean Wehner came forward describing similar horrors. When the archdiocese asked for corroboration, Wehner’s family sent postcards to every girl in her yearbook asking whether they had been abused. Dozens responded yes.
Lancaster was one. Together, she and Wehner became plaintiffs in a 1994 lawsuit against the Baltimore Archdiocese. Wehner was Jane Doe; Lancaster was Jane Roe. The pair argued that their memories should propel the case forward even though the abuse predated the statute of limitations.
After many years, hundreds of legal filings, a Netflix hit and more twists and turns than a true crime podcast, the women may finally see justice. A federal judge will hold a hearing Thursday and Friday that attorneys on both sides hope will lead to a settlement.
‘The Keepers’
Maskell denied the allegations. The archdiocese arranged for him to participate in therapy at a Connecticut facility. He returned in 1993, according to the archdiocese, because the organization was “unable to corroborate the allegation of sexual abuse through its own investigation.” But the church removed him as a priest, keeping him employed in other capacities.
Though the archdiocese maintained it had no records of Maskell’s abuse before Jane Doe/Jane Roe, a 2023 report by Maryland’s attorney general describes the reason behind removing him from an all-boys school and putting him in an all-girls setting.
“Joseph Maskell was moved from two parishes in the 1960s because of reports of troubling behavior with children, including a fascination with the sexual fantasies and behavior of boy scouts and ‘having young girls in the rectory under suspicious circumstances,’” the report says.
In 1975, the archdiocese moved him again, to an administrative position. He died in 2000. The attorney general’s report says he left at least 39 victims.
“The archdiocese acknowledges the abuse Teresa Lancaster suffered as a child at the hands of one of its priests and the lasting pain that abuse has caused,” archdiocesan spokesperson Christian Kendzierski said in an email last week. “We are deeply sorry for the harm she experienced.”
In 1994, Lancaster reached a modest settlement — $40,000 — with the archdiocesan lawyer that released the archdiocese from all future claims regarding Maskell. But she vowed that the archdiocese had not seen the last of her.
At age 48, she went to law school and began representing survivors of sex abuse — mostly pro bono while she also took other cases. She was a major force behind “The Keepers,” the Netflix documentary that unspooled the abuse at Keough and investigated the murder of a popular nun, Catherine Cesnik, who was purportedly planning to turn Maskell in when she disappeared.
Lancaster was among those pushing the Maryland attorney general’s office to release its 2023 report detailing the abuse of 600 children by 156 Catholic clergy since the 1940s. The abuse took place at parishes and schools. She also lobbied the Maryland General Assembly to pass the Maryland Child Victims Act, which removed the statute of limitations restrictions on how much time the survivors have to sue their perpetrators.
C.T. Wilson, the delegate-turned-senator who championed the bills, said Lancaster was there every step of the way for a decade as he tried to get the legislation passed. The Charles County Democrat, himself a survivor of child abuse by his adoptive father, said other survivors sometimes gave up — and he doesn’t blame them.
By speaking up, as Lancaster has, “you forgo your greatest desire, which is to have a normal life, to become a poster child for the worst thing that has ever happened in your life,” Wilson said.
On Sept. 29, 2023, two days before the Maryland Child Victims Act became law, Lancaster stood in shock as the Archdiocese of Baltimore declared bankruptcy. That move effectively froze more than 900 sex abuse claims from proceeding in Maryland state courts.
Now, she is representing three dozen survivors at Thursday’s hearing. Factoring in expected settlements from insurance companies, the money for survivors could top $100 million.
Survivors’ attorneys say it’s not enough. They also won’t take a settlement unless the church adopts safeguards to protect minors, something the church says it has done. The judge has warned the parties that she may remove bankruptcy protection on Nov. 20 — leverage to force an end to the litigation, which has cost the archdiocese millions of dollars.
“All the guns were fired at once,” Lancaster said. “It was ‘The Keepers.’ It was the attorney general’s report, and people reading hundreds of pages of what these children went through, finally. ... And instead of saying, ‘Oh, they were abused,’ they heard the words. They were raped anally, orally, bloodily. Let’s hear the dirty words because that’s what was suffered.”
‘The face of the abuse’
Those who know her say Lancaster was one of the most important of those metaphorical guns.
Frank Schindler recalls sporadic media coverage when he organized protests after the bankruptcy filing. But when Lancaster and Wehner showed up at the archdiocese offices, the cameras would, too.
“Teresa was the face of the abuse, a recognizable face, and had a story she was bravely able to share,” Schindler said. “There was enormous value in her being able to do that, to expose it, and to never let up.”
When survivors are afraid of retaliation, Lancaster becomes their proxy, said Annie Copeland, Lancaster’s researcher.
“She still takes calls from frustrated and upset clients every week and reassures them,” Copeland said.
After a 2002 Boston Globe investigation spotlighted how priests accused of abuse were shuffled to unsuspecting parishes, archdioceses nationwide began a slow reckoning. The Baltimore Archdiocese issued a report naming a few dozen abusive priests. But according to the 2023 Maryland attorney general’s report, that candor didn’t last.
“The incontrovertible history uncovered by this investigation is one of pervasive and persistent abuse by priests and other Archdiocese personnel,” the report says. “It is also a history of repeated dismissal or cover up of that abuse by the Catholic Church hierarchy.”
None of Lancaster’s advocacy has been easy. In Lancaster’s first year of law school, her mother-in-law died in a fire, her father fell down a flight of stairs and died, and her grandson succumbed to a brain injury. Today, she is the primary caregiver for her second husband, Randy Lancaster, who has Alzheimer’s and coronary artery disease.
John Benam met Lancaster when he was the director of photography for “The Keepers.” It has been translated into 26 languages and is among the most-watched series in Netflix history.
Lancaster could have left the struggle behind when the judge dismissed her case. Instead, Benam said, she doubled down.
“For her to navigate everything that she went through and then go to school and become a lawyer, because she was like, ‘Oh, I’m just gonna fix this myself, if no one’s gonna do anything about it?’ that’s pretty extraordinary,” Benam said.
Her calm demeanor has thawed some heated discussions. A survivors committee, led by Paul Jan Zdunek, has been negotiating with the archdiocese. But the talks are confidential, complicating how Zdunek can brief the larger survivor network. Lancaster has helped bridge the divide.
“She is a great voice of reason,” Zdunek said. “And she has been at every hearing, at every moment.”
The girl who wanted to be somebody became several somebodies — lawyer, advocate, author, mother, wife. She finds peace at the river outside her south Annapolis home, in hugging her children and watching her cat, Nimbus, stretch out on the piano.
Whatever happens on Thursday will not be the end. There are cases everywhere.
When her phone rings, she will take the call.




Comments
Welcome to The Banner's subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.